West Virginia enacts law restricting men from accessing women's spaces
By bellecarter // 2025-03-23
Copy
 
  • West Virginia Governor Patrick Morrisey signed SB 456 into law, restricting access to women’s spaces (restrooms, changing rooms, sleeping quarters) in public schools, colleges, shelters and correctional facilities based on biological sex. The law takes effect on June 9.
  • The bill aims to protect women and girls from harassment, abuse and violence by defining male and female based on "biological sex," determined by chromosomes, hormones and reproductive anatomy at birth.
  • Proponents, including conservative groups like the Alliance Defending Freedom, argue the law safeguards privacy and safety for women. Critics, however, warn it marginalizes transgender individuals, particularly transgender women and perpetuates discrimination.
  • The law reflects a broader trend in conservative states to legislate gender-segregated spaces, often in response to federal efforts to expand transgender protections. It aligns with ongoing cultural and political debates over gender identity and rights.
  • SB 456 is expected to face legal challenges, similar to other state laws, with potential implications for civil rights and public policy regarding gender identity. The law highlights deep societal divides over biological sex versus gender identity.
On March 12, West Virginia Gov. Patrick Morrisey signed into law SB 456, a controversial bill aimed at restricting men from accessing women's spaces, including restrooms, changing rooms and sleeping quarters in public schools, colleges, domestic violence shelters and correctional facilities. The legislation, which defines male and female based on biological sex, is set to take effect on June 9. Proponents argue the law is necessary to protect women and girls from potential harassment and abuse, while critics warn it could further marginalize transgender individuals. The bill's passage comes amid a national debate over gender identity and the rights of transgender individuals to access spaces that align with their gender. West Virginia's move reflects a broader trend in conservative-led states to legislate boundaries around gender-segregated spaces, often citing concerns over privacy and safety. SB 456 explicitly states its purpose is to "preserve women's restrooms, multiple occupancy restrooms or changing rooms and sleeping quarters for women in facilities where women have been traditionally afforded privacy and safety from acts of abuse, harassment, sexual assault and violence committed by men." The law applies to public institutions, including schools and shelters, and defines male and female based on "biological sex," which it describes as "the physical condition of being male or female, as determined by an individual's sex chromosomes, naturally occurring sex hormones and internal and external reproductive anatomy at birth."

Legal and advocacy responses

The legislation has drawn praise from conservative legal groups, including the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), which has been at the forefront of advocating for similar measures nationwide. Sara Beth Nolan, ADF Legal Counsel, commended the law, stating, "States have a duty to protect the privacy, safety and dignity of women and girls." "Letting men intrude into girls' spaces where they are most vulnerable – whether in a changing space, sleeping quarters or the restroom, is an invasion of privacy, a threat to their safety and a denial of the real biological differences between the two sexes," Nolan warned. She also praised West Virginia's leadership for their role in advancing the bill, calling it a victory for women's rights. (Related: California defies Trump's executive order, continues allowing transgender athletes in girls' sports.) However, critics argue that the law unfairly targets transgender individuals, particularly transgender women, who may face increased discrimination and exclusion as a result. Advocates for LGBTQ+ rights have long contended that such legislation perpetuates stigma and denies transgender people access to safe and affirming spaces. West Virginia's law is part of a wave of similar measures introduced in conservative states over the past decade. These laws often emerge in response to federal and state efforts to expand protections for transgender individuals, such as the Obama-era guidance allowing transgender students to use restrooms matching their gender identity. That guidance was later rescinded under the Trump administration, leaving states to set their own policies. The debate over gender-segregated spaces is deeply rooted in broader cultural and political divides over gender identity and the rights of transgender individuals. Proponents of laws like SB 456 argue that biological sex is an immutable characteristic that should dictate access to certain spaces, while opponents emphasize the importance of recognizing gender identity as a fundamental aspect of personal dignity. Watch the video below where President Donald Trump bans men in women's sports. This video is from the Cynthia's Pursuit of Truth channel on Brighteon.com.

More related stories:

Trump signs orders banning transgender service members and eliminating DEI programs in the U.S. military. Trump bans federal funding for chemical and surgical mutilation of children. Trump signs executive orders reversing transgender protections and DEI programs. Sources include: LifeSiteNews.com WVLegislature.gov Brighteon.com
Copy