William Bonner and Lila Rajiva explore the world of finance and politics in "Mobs, Messiahs and Markets"
By ramontomeydw // 2025-06-19
Copy
 
  • The book "Mobs, Messiahs and Markets" examines figures like Saddam Hussein and Armin Meiwes, who justified extreme actions (e.g., cannibalism, dictatorship) under the guise of solving societal problems. These leaders, like financial bubbles, succumb to self-delusion and hype.
  • Comparisons are drawn between Alexander the Great's messianic conquests and George W. Bush’s foreign policy, highlighting how modern interventions – despite technological advantages – often ignore local complexities, leading to prolonged instability.
  •  The authors liken historical witch hunts to today's scandal-driven news cycles, arguing that media fixation on lurid stories (e.g., child abuse) diverts attention from systemic issues like inequality or corruption, reinforcing power structures.
  • Democracy is critiqued as vulnerable to elite manipulation and voter irrationality. The book contrasts Hong Kong's economic success under non-democratic rule with democratic stagnation, suggesting governance systems often fail in practice.
  • The book condemns blind faith in markets, exemplified by Alan Greenspan’s role in the housing bubble. It warns against overconfidence in predictive models, advocating humility, skepticism and social intelligence over spectacle-driven decision-making.
William Bonner and Lila Rajiva's 2009 book "Mobs, Messiahs and Markets: Surviving the Public Spectacle in Finance and Politics" offers a sharp critique of how mass psychology is manipulated in finance and politics. It exposes the dangers of self-delusion, media sensationalism and misguided leadership. The book opens with an examination of "world improvers," individuals who believe they can solve humanity's problems but often cause more harm than good. Among its examples is Armin Meiwes, the "Rotenburg Cannibal" who justified eating other humans as a solution to overpopulation. Iraq's Saddam Hussein, whose brutal regime was masked by claims of progress, is another example the authors use. They argue that such figures share a common trait. They fall victim to their own hype, much like financial bubbles where irrational exuberance distorts reality. The book draws parallels between historical and modern leaders, comparing Alexander the Great's conquests driven by a messianic vision of spreading "liberty" to George W. Bush’s foreign policy ambitions. Both leaders, the authors suggest, were propelled by a sense of destiny. While Alexander's reach was limited by ancient logistics, Bush's wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were amplified by modern technology and geopolitics, leading to prolonged instability. This critique extends to democratic interventions, where the authors argue that exporting democracy often ignores local complexities, resulting in costly failures. Media manipulation is another central theme. Bonner and Rajiva compare historical witch trials, fueled by pamphlets spreading hysteria, to today's sensationalist news cycles. They criticize how modern media prioritizes scandal over substantive issues, distorting public perception. For instance, while child abuse is a serious problem, media fixation on lurid details can overshadow systemic issues like economic inequality or political corruption. The authors contend that this spectacle-driven coverage serves power structures by diverting attention from deeper societal failures. Democracy itself is scrutinized, with the authors questioning its effectiveness when corrupted by money and propaganda. They contrast Hong Kong’s economic success under a non-democratic system with the inefficiencies and stagnation plaguing many democracies. The book suggests that democratic governance, while noble in theory, is often undermined by elite manipulation and voter irrationality. The role of intuition versus rationality is also explored. Using the 2005 London bombings as an example, the authors show how fear can override logic, leading to disproportionate reactions. They emphasize social intelligence, particularly in women, as a crucial but undervalued skill in navigating complex social and political landscapes. Finance receives harsh criticism, with the book condemning overconfidence in markets. Alan Greenspan, once hailed as a financial sage, is rebuked for fueling the housing bubble through misguided policies. The authors argue that blind faith in market efficiency and predictive models ignores inherent unpredictability, leading to crises. Ultimately, "Mobs, Messiahs and Markets" serves as a cautionary tale against the seduction of grand narratives, whether in politics, media or finance. It urges skepticism toward self-proclaimed saviors, sensationalist distractions and economic hubris, advocating instead for humility, critical thinking and trust in instinct over spectacle. Watch this video about the book "Mobs, Messiahs and Markets: Surviving the Public Spectacle in Finance and Politics" by William Bonner and Lila Rajiva. This video is from the BrightLearn channel on Brighteon.com. Sources include: Brighteon.ai Brighteon.com
Copy